Open post
Ronderings podcast artwork featuring Dr. Kimberlin Butler as the guest of host Ron Rapatalo

Hold Up an X-Ray, Not a Mirror: Youth Power and Possibility in Philanthropy

Ronderings Podcast | Episode 118 | November 4, 2026

What happens when young people are invited to share their perspectives, but those perspectives never influence what happens next?

That question is at the heart of a recent episode of Ronderings, where host Ron Rapatalo welcomes Dr. Kimberlin Butler, Founder and Chief Possibility Catalyst of The L.E.A.D. Agency, for a conversation about youth power in philanthropy, shared decision-making, and the possibilities that emerge when institutions trust young people to help shape their futures.

Drawing on her journey from growing up in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, and attending Head Start to leading national philanthropic initiatives and earning her doctorate at the University of Pennsylvania, Dr. Butler reflects on the people, relationships, and opportunities that helped shape her understanding of possibility.

She also explores how those experiences informed Youth-Possible Philanthropy®, her research-informed, field-building framework designed to move institutions beyond youth engagement toward meaningful intergenerational partnership and shared power.

Listen to the full Ronderings podcast episode with Dr. Kimberlin Butler.

Youth Voice Is Not the Same as Youth Power

One of the conversation’s central distinctions is the difference between being heard and having influence.

Inviting young people to speak at conferences, participate in advisory groups, or share their personal stories can create opportunities for engagement. But meaningful participation requires more: their perspectives must influence decisions, institutional strategies, investments, and outcomes.

The question is not simply whether young people were invited into the room. It is whether anything changed because they were there.

Why Philanthropy Needs an X-Ray, Not a Mirror

Dr. Butler challenges philanthropic institutions to examine what lies beneath their stated commitments to youth engagement.

A mirror reflects what is already visible. An X-ray reveals what may otherwise go unnoticed.

For philanthropy, that means examining assumptions about young people’s capabilities, the distribution of decision-making authority, and whether institutional practices create genuine opportunities for shared power.

The episode also explores the experience of Maya, a young woman whose story was repeatedly celebrated on prominent stages while her personal circumstances went largely unseen by the institutions inviting her to speak.

Her experience raises important questions about the difference between elevating a young person’s story and recognizing their humanity, expertise, and need for meaningful institutional follow-through.

What Shared Power Looks Like in Practice

The conversation highlights the Peter & Elizabeth Tower Foundation’s Community Experts Team, where young people and adults with lived experience help shape grantmaking opportunities, review applications, and make funding decisions.

Through The L.E.A.D. Agency’s learning and evaluation partnership, Dr. Butler also facilitated a Possibility Lab, creating space for participants to interpret evaluation findings and help shape recommendations for the initiative’s future.

This example illustrates a central principle of Youth-Possible Philanthropy®: young people are not simply contributors to institutional learning. They can help generate knowledge, influence investments, and shape how systems evolve.

Possibility Development: Moving Beyond Encouragement

A distinguishing element of Youth-Possible Philanthropy® is possibility development: the process through which young people come to perceive possibilities in their lives and act to pursue them.

Encouragement alone is not enough. Young people also need access to relationships, social capital, meaningful responsibilities, resources, and opportunities that help them imagine and pursue their futures.

When institutions invest in both young people’s agency and the conditions that support it, possibility becomes more than an aspiration. It becomes something young people can actively shape.

Building the Youth-Possible Philanthropy® Practice Network

Dr. Butler also shares her vision for the emerging Youth-Possible Philanthropy® Practice Network, an initiative designed to bring young people and philanthropic partners together to learn, practice shared power, and develop approaches that can influence institutional practice over time.

The vision is to move beyond isolated examples of promising work toward sustained opportunities for young people and funders to co-create philanthropic strategies, test approaches, and share learning across the field.

Rather than simply asking institutions to listen more closely, the Practice Network is intended to help them build the relationships and infrastructure needed to share consequential decision-making power with young people.

A Question for Philanthropic Leaders

Near the close of the conversation, Dr. Butler offers a reminder:

“The future does not simply belong to young people. It must be shaped with them.”

For foundations, boards, educators, nonprofit leaders, and others working alongside young people, this raises an important question:

Where are young people being invited to participate, and where are they genuinely trusted to lead?

The distinction matters. So does what institutions choose to do next.

Listen to “Hold Up an X-Ray, Not a Mirror” on the Ronderings Podcast.

Learn more about Youth-Possible Philanthropy® at The L.E.A.D. Agency.

Open post
Graphic comparing traditional evaluation questions with causal thinking questions about how, why, for whom, and under what conditions change happens.

Planting the Seeds of Causal Thinking

A New Reflection on Understanding How Systems Change

How can foundations, organizations, and communities better understand how change is happening—not simply whether a program or strategy “worked”?

In a new blog post for the Causal Pathways Initiative, The L.E.A.D. Agency’s Founder and Chief Possibility Catalyst, Dr. Kimberlin Butler, joins Alison Gold to explore how causal thinking can become part of everyday strategy, learning, and decision-making.

The post introduces five questions:

  • How did things change?
  • Why did they change?
  • For whom did change occur?
  • Under what conditions did change happen?
  • According to whom?

These questions reflect The L.E.A.D. Agency’s commitment to participatory and emergent learning. Understanding change requires more than one organizational or institutional perspective. It also requires listening to people whose lives are directly shaped by systems and recognizing their lived expertise as essential knowledge.

Causal thinking does not have to begin with a formal evaluation. It can begin with a better question, a newly visible assumption, or an honest conversation about what is changing and what that learning asks us to do differently.

Read the full blog post on the Causal Pathways website.

Open post
Community Experts Team members and partners participating in a facilitated group discussion during the Tower Foundation’s participatory grantmaking process.

Power Shared, Possibility Realized: Youth-Possible Philanthropy® in Practice at the Peter & Elizabeth Tower Foundation

Originally published as a Perspectives piece by Grantmakers for Effective Organizations (GEO).

What does shared power look like when young people are trusted not only to advise philanthropy, but to make decisions?

This Perspectives piece explores the Peter & Elizabeth Tower Foundation’s Community Experts Team (CET), a participatory grantmaking model in which young people with lived experience help design the grantmaking process and make funding decisions. It illustrates Youth-Possible Philanthropy® in practice—bringing together youth participatory grantmaking, trust-based philanthropy, an equity-centered approach, multi-sector collaboration, participatory learning, and possibility development.

The piece also highlights The L.E.A.D. Agency’s role as a learning partner to the Foundation and the CET Possibility Lab, where young people engaged directly with evaluation findings, interpreted what the learning meant, and helped identify possibilities for the program’s future.

At its core, the story asks philanthropy to move beyond inviting youth into existing structures and toward creating the conditions for young people to share power, shape meaning, and lead.

Read the full Perspectives piece at Grantmakers for Effective Organizations.

Open post
Branded featured image for “Engaging Youth in Philanthropic Practice,” showing The L.E.A.D. Agency and The Foundation Review branding and highlighting Youth-Possible Philanthropy®.

Engaging Youth in Philanthropic Practice: Field-Building Strategies and the Promise of Youth-Possible Philanthropy®

Originally published in The Foundation Review, Volume 17, Issue 1 (2025).

How might philanthropy change if young people were positioned not simply as participants, but as co-creators and possibility catalysts?

In this peer-reviewed article, Dr. Kimberlin D. Butler introduces Youth-Possible Philanthropy®, a field-building framework for strengthening meaningful youth participation, shared decision-making, and power-sharing in philanthropic practice. The article examines persistent gaps in how philanthropy engages young people and explores how possibility development, participatory approaches, and trust-based philanthropy can help create more authentic roles for youth in philanthropic governance and strategy.

The article also offers strategies and examples for moving from intention to practice—creating conditions in which young people can help shape decisions about the issues, communities, and futures that affect them.

Read the full article in The Foundation Review.

Suggested citation:
Butler, K. D. (2025). Engaging Youth in Philanthropic Practice: Field-Building Strategies and the Promise of Youth-Possible Philanthropy™. The Foundation Review, 17(1). https://doi.org/10.9707/1944-5660.1725

Scroll to top